The Lord of The Rings Analysis

All of this has been made without having the right to adopt the first two ages of Middle Earth, but merely the appendixes of the third generation about what had happened before. The history and stories of 3500 years run in nonchronological order and liberties had to be taken in the story.

This sounds concerning to me and most likely to other fans of the books. But it actually works, mostly at least some elements like the dialogue can come across as a bit clunky in comparison to conversations coming from Tolkien’s hand.

Also instead of going on a route of many different characters in the beginning Galadriel gets a lot of focus, whilst as a viewer, there is no instant connection with her persona.

Dialogues: 6/10

Good at best, boring and odd at other times. The forced emphasis on getting the pronunciation of Galadriel right is a bit ridiculous, especially since her name comes up quite a bit. And sometimes the daunting task of creating dialogue that fits in Middle Earth fails. But in general, the dialogue is ok to watch.

Cast Performance: 6.5/10

There is room for improvement as some of the halflings and elves need to grow in their role. The acting is sometimes a bit theatrical (due to the script). It seems to be expected, that this will loosen up as the series progresses. Most of the actors are lesser know, so the actual focus can be on the story instead. Some stand-outs, Robert Aramayo as Elrond can be rough at times, but Owain Arthur as Durin is very convincing.

Visuals & Decors of the Show: 10/10

No complaints, it looks great, and it is a feast for the eyes. It is here where the series shines

Costumes & Makeup: 7.5/10

Very well, but not as good as Game of Thrones, sometimes the characters look like actors from Earth today in costume. Instead of being an integral part of the Middle Earth universe

Music: 7.5/10

Good and fitting during the show in the background. Although the intro and outdo songs are traditionally cinematic and could have been more epic.

Creative Liberties: 7/10

While the pace and cinematics are fantastic. The original dialogue is both good and bad variably. The halfling’s inclusion and some other liberties can take you a bit out of the original lore. But as much concern, I had prior to release, it is at no means inherently bad.

The Lord of The Rings: The Rings of Powerr Review: Final Verdict

So how good is it, and why? It is an ambitious project that comes with its flaws, but that is not what matters at the end of the day.

The question is: is it watchable and fun? and that surely is. It looks good, and the rough edges on the points discussed earlier may clear up as the series progresses.

It is fun and exciting to watch and whilst the first episodes don’t totally suck you in, they will please people and will leave the majority of people wondering for more.